Beams to follow ceiling plane


LevisL
 Share

Recommended Posts

Is there a framing member type/setting that I'm missing here? I'm trying to put in beams to follow the ceiling (underside of scissor trusses). These would just be decorative. I've tried all the different types of framing members but I can't seem to find one that'll follow the ceiling.

post-108-0-28169600-1447973195_thumb.png

 

The closest I can get is using Polyline Solids, but the wood grain goes in the wrong direction, so I'd have to explode them and create copies of the material at different angles...

post-108-0-96087300-1447973247_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I haven't tried this but have you tried a set of "Ceiling Planes" to match the bottom chord of the trusses and then "Framing" the Ceiling?

 

If not Ceiling Planes then maybe Roof Planes.  Once the Framing is done you can delete the Ceiling or Roof Plane and "retain framing".

 

It might be easiest to do this on a copy of the plan and then create a symbol of the ceiling framing which could be placed in your plan.  Multiple Roof Plane Framing within a plan can be tricky to control.  OTOH, with trusses it's not as difficult to superimpose.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I believe what I've always done in the past is...

Frame a small ceiling or roof at the correct pitch (even just a small section), take one of the rafters and put it on it's own layer " decorative beams" maybe), delete what you don't need, and then adjust/copy/distribute the new rafter as necessary.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I haven't tried this but have you tried a set of "Ceiling Planes" to match the bottom chord of the trusses and then "Framing" the Ceiling?

 

If not Ceiling Planes then maybe Roof Planes.  Once the Framing is done you can delete the Ceiling or Roof Plane and "retain framing".

 

It might be easiest to do this on a copy of the plan and then create a symbol of the ceiling framing which could be placed in your plan.  Multiple Roof Plane Framing within a plan can be tricky to control.  OTOH, with trusses it's not as difficult to superimpose.

 

I ended up doing a slight variation of your suggestion. I locked the truss envelope and replaced the ceiling planes with another set of roof planes at the same slope as the underside of the trusses (ceiling surface, fascia, etc. turned off). Then I used roof beams and they followed the lower roof planes. 

 

If it's just for decoration you can use Soffits - they can be set up to follow the slope of the ceiling plane. Check out page 779 of the X7 Reference Manual.

 

Soffits work...sorta... I kept getting an error message that it couldn't find a ceiling plane above??? I got it to work by checking sloped soffit instead and figuring out my heights in a cross-section view. Still, after doing all that, that method is no better than polyline solids... the orientation of the wood grain was wrong too. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why not just draw a rafter, and then set it to the dept and width you want.   Lower it with transform replicate 'move' in the "z" plane.

 

Of course polyline solids will work too...as will soffit tool, but for something like that, a simple rafter might do the trick.

 

I used polyline solids to build these dec trusses.   I wanted the detail of the reveals created by hanging the outer trim boards down slightly.

 

Lots of ways to skin a cat...

post-3615-0-37047800-1447989857_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I ended up doing a slight variation of your suggestion. I locked the truss envelope and replaced the ceiling planes with another set of roof planes at the same slope as the underside of the trusses (ceiling surface, fascia, etc. turned off). Then I used roof beams and they followed the lower roof planes. 

I'm happy that worked for you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why not just draw a rafter, and then set it to the dept and width you want.   Lower it with transform replicate 'move' in the "z" plane.

I had tried that but the rafters were picking up the roof slope (4:12) as opposed to the ceiling slope (2:12)...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Use a sloped ceiling plane and build the framing. Select one of the ceiling joist, copy and lower it. Resize and change the materials to that of the beam you want. Once you are satisfied, copy it in plan to complete your scheme.

 

The only problem with this method, I found, is that the beams (ceiling joist, really) will be deleted if you have to rebuild the framing of these ceiling planes. Placing them on a separate layer and locking it did not help. Maybe someone else could chime in with a fix for this problem.

post-571-0-14305100-1448142440_thumb.jpg

post-571-0-85179900-1448142455_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Use a sloped ceiling plane and build the framing. Select one of the ceiling joist, copy and lower it. Resize and change the materials to that of the beam you want. Once you are satisfied, copy it in plan to complete your scheme.

 

The only problem with this method, I found, is that the beams (ceiling joist, really) will be deleted if you have to rebuild the framing of these ceiling planes. Placing them on a separate layer and locking it did not help. Maybe someone else could chime in with a fix for this problem.

 

This is pretty much the method I had previously described above.  When I made that post I was away from my computer so I was just going off memory.  I went back and checked what I've done in the past though...

 

In my particular instance, I just left the ceiling plane in place and checked "Use Room Ceiling Finish".  It seems you would need a ceiling plane anyway for the roof in question.  Or you could create a second ceiling plane and just give it a finish with no material.  There are a number of other variations you can utilize and settings you could play with, but that's what worked for me. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

.......The only problem with this method, I found, is that the beams (ceiling joist, really) will be deleted if you have to rebuild the framing of these ceiling planes......

 

 

I hear what you are saying,  but the mistake you are making is you are not building your own rafter.  Build your own rafter (not an auto rafter dependent on a roof/ceiling plane),  and it will stay in place no matter what you do  with the roof  plane and it's rafters.

 

 

If I am wrong,  post a plan where this does not work and I will take a  look at it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Build your own rafter (not an auto rafter dependent on a roof/ceiling plane),  and it will stay in place no matter what you do  with the roof  plane and it's rafters.

 

Agreed, except the OP wants the beams to follow the lowered, sloped (ceiling) plane (see post #1 and #12), not the roof.

 

But since you suggested it, how do you change the pitch of a manually placed roof rafter?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

....But since you suggested it, how do you change the pitch of a manually placed roof rafter?

Put in a temp roof,  draw the rafter,  delete the temp roof.......  you could also do this to define the slope of a rafter for a sloped ceiling plane.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Put in a temp roof,  draw the rafter,  delete the temp roof.......  you could also do this to define the slope of a rafter for a sloped ceiling plane.

 

that does not work,  once the roof is deleted,  the rafter goes away....  good question

Link to comment
Share on other sites

they stay if you block them together before re-building.

I think the problem with that is once framing is blocked,  they are not visible in 3D.

 

I will never forget that first day you and I were in Monte's class in San Diego,  and he blocked some footings and posts and girders,  and they were not visible in 3D.  The solution to see them was to unblock them.

 

Hey P.,  do you guys want the San Diego  Chargers? We don't want them anymore.......  we are trying to get New England or Cincinnati to move out here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes I remember, if you do your 3d prior to blocking it will be good, but really why after 10+ years, can't Chief fix that. We used to ask to show blocked framing for many years, I guess we gave up and forgot. I guess that's why Chief recommends to frame last. I actually frame very early on. I actually use p-solids for those.

Boy the chargers stink this year, maybe it's on purpose, so the league will grant the move. we do need someone, why are we getting 2 teams, I don't get it.

New England ,Wow, if you get them, good deal, but I think if they are willing to move ,LA should have them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think the problem with that is once framing is blocked,  they are not visible in 3D.

 

You are right, Scott. The question is why are CAD Blocks not visible in 3D?

 

And why is there not an option to set the slope of a manually placed rafter (like there is with a CAD line)? And why can't these rafters be placed on a separate layer and lock? And why is wood grain impossible to manage when using Soffits, which is touted as the go-to tool for this sort of work? A lot of ink spilled here for something that should be fairly straight forward.

 

It seems the only option for preserving your work is to block (to keep them from being deleted when rebuilding the framing), and then to unblock in order to view them in 3D. Either that, or make them into a symbol.

 

For those who may not know, both CAD Blocks and Symbols can be added to the library for later use.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

that does not work,  once the roof is deleted,  the rafter goes away....  good question

It works sir, you were correct.

Retain rafters after deleting the roof. Here is the plan for confirmation. I have deleted the side that has the gable and framing is there. This setting is helpful in a lot of areas when working in chief.

post-2517-0-78184400-1448234513_thumb.jpg

retain rafters.plan

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ok I know this is silly, but the power to store temporarily using clipboard is very helpfull. I use it most of the time before doing any action that affects some part of the job. This case make a temporary roof then place rafters as Scott said. Finally Before deleting the roof , just copy it and paste it back holding its position.

The niche techniqu I posted last time was applying this technique. Draw walls, apply the material region, copy the material region, place the window niche and finally paste hold position and the material region will not be cut by the window. This is just FYI and i would realy like, if chief could have an option to store temporarily minimum ,a list of the last 5 copied items. and let me choose which one to paste currently. Just a thought, in my oppenion this would increase some efficiency.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now
 Share

  • Member Statistics

    31608
    Total Members
    9156
    Most Online
    FireflyHomes
    Newest Member
    FireflyHomes
    Joined
  • Similar Content

    • By ACADuser
      Creating a Header schedule I select one row & click the "Find Object in Plan" which takes me to the wall frame view instead of the plan view.
      Do I have a setting off or is this normal?


    • By KRosen
      So I'm trying to get my rafter ends to show up like so (please ignore the rafter tails for all intent and purposes). I've tried adjusting the birdsmouth settings to get the desired result but no matter what I do, I can't get the seat cut. I can only get a plumb cut or a square cut, and the plumb cut is going through the floor and walls. Can someone please help, because this is driving me crazy! (also the steeper roof pitch is 25":12")

    • By Designer100
      !) Need family windows from floor all the way to btm of roof 7.5x5.5 beams like picture.any ideals?
      2) Need to design beams that are arched like picture. Any ideals. 


      Gibson.Dan.Martha.zip
    • By TimelessJohn
      Hi All,
       
      "Roof Beams Appear as Solid Timbers not I-Beams as Preferred."
       
      I have a small insignificant detail problem that I wish to resolve and wonder if anyone has a Tip or Trick to fixing the fact that my Steel I Beams show up perfectly in my Posts and Deck patio beams but not in my roof beams.
       
      I have changed all of my defaults to I Beams in my settings to no avail, just curious if this a detail I will have to learn to live with or a glitch in Chief?
       
      Also I would like my I beams to show in the interior walls and imagine in order for this to happen I will need to create a niche and paint it black steel? Correct?
       
      Please see attached image.
       
      Thank you in advance,
      John
      Modders ADU Plan V3.plan
    • By No1ZZTopfan
      In need a bit of assistance, please. I'd like to place the cabinet door panel onto the curved polyline shape shown in the attachment. Would anyone have a suggestion(s)? I'd be most grateful. Thanks.