Critique my layout, please


OneChickNoHammer
 Share

Recommended Posts

Hello,

I'm sorry if I am posting this in the wrong category, but I honestly couldn't decide where the best place for this was.

 

I am seeking a constructive critique of this set of drawings.  This is for my very first client and while this municipality does not require this much detail, I wanted to include it just in case.  I'm hoping to receive a general critique of the overall work I drafted. 

  • Is there anything substantial that I'm missing?
  • Should I really include a Roof Framing page?
  • Is there anything glaringly wrong with my construction details?
  • Are there details that I should've included?

 

The client will be picking out the specific materials when the time comes.  However, the client has definitely decided he wants a full brick veneer and the brick soldier courses over the windows.

 

I appreciate any time anyone could devote to this,

Lisa M. Fida

Timber Bay Home Design

Anita III - Basement - Reversed.pdf

Link to comment
Share on other sites

looks good to me, I might do two things. 1. remove the elevation cameras from the floor plan. 2. on the roof layout only have one line at the edge. There are two layers that control this, overhang, and I dont remember the other one. I like to dimension the eaves to ensure they are correct.

 

There is more information in yours than is required here.

 

I would not include a roof framing page, but I show a trusss in my section. I see your section have detail 7, but i dont see it on the section. you have a 7-8 but that is the floor not the roof

 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not sure the type of soil this house be sitting on, but that would be one hell of a concrete pour... 51yrd. of concrete for a footing and foundation for a little house. Also why would you set brick on the angle iron and not a concrete ledge?

Edited by Greg_NY61
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anita III

 

If you're from Portugal, this is very good in matching what is typical in America, so congratulations.   I see you're drawing it for a city in Kentucky.

 

On sheet two, under general framing notes, typically the language I would use is all dimensions are from face of framing or foundation, not the framing layer because in Chief there are layers, but then in reality there might be layers as well, and it just makes it more specific.

 

On sheet two, there is two different uses of the word undimensioned, which is not even really a word.  The first use is all one word and the second use under electrical notes has a hyphen in between the first two letters and the third letter.

 

Maybe that should be rephrased and you could run that text through AI and have it rephrase it for you, but it should say something like all doors that are not dimensioned or something like that.

 

On sheet 4, there are dimensions to the sixteenth of an inch that show, to me, sloppiness, and you should move the walls to the nearest whole or half inch. So on the left, where it says 12'-3-15/16", it should actually be lengthened to be 12'-4". The whole building is a weird size; 30'-9-7/8" should be 30'-10". There's no concrete guy on planet earth that's going to nail that 1/8", so put it on your plans to the nearest inch or half inch, but nothing smaller. The only time dimensions get as small as that is if you're connecting an angled wall to a horizontal or vertical wall and dimensioning over to that point, which often will have a very small or odd remainder.  This whole structure on the foundation should be 30'-10" wide by 28'-10" deep or tall, up and down on the sheet, that is.

 

What is strange is your floor plan view for first and second floor have dimensions that look much better, a 30' wide. The building is 30'-0" wide by 28'-0" deep so I'm guessing the foundation is out over the brick in its dimensions but still, they need to not be to a 1/16". In reality not even to an 1/8 and your hallway is 3'-7-7/8"

 

Are you planning on stick framing this roof or using trusses?

 

Sheet 7. By looking at your elevations, it looks like you're using 11-7/8" I-joists for the first floor and second floor but where is your saved plan view that shows the foundation with the floor framing in it and the second floor framing so that you can show how you frame around your stair openings and stuff?  You have room on sheet four to copy and paste your foundation saved plan view and rename it floor framing and actually draw the joists or at least indicate how the joists are being installed.   the two elevations on the left have the first floor top of plate at the correct elevation. The two on the right are off and not what they should be. Are you dimensioning to something different? 

 

Sheet 10:
Detail 8   It calls out 2x12 floor joists or I joists. It should say joists per plan, and then somewhere on your plan, you should annotate the size of materials.

 

Detail 7.  Again, you are specifying 2x12 rafter, and I've framed many houses in Kentucky and Tennessee, and the largest rafter we used was 2x8, so I'm curious why you're specifying 2x12.

 

Stairs with 11 inch treads.pdf

Edited by para-CAD
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 hours ago, GeneDavis said:

Is this a practice run?  Why no structural?

Yes, this is a practice run.  I thought I did include at least some structural....  I showed the foundation and footings, etc.  What else am I missing????

 

Thank you so much!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, SHCanada2 said:

looks good to me, I might do two things. 1. remove the elevation cameras from the floor plan. 2. on the roof layout only have one line at the edge. There are two layers that control this, overhang, and I dont remember the other one. I like to dimension the eaves to ensure they are correct.

 

There is more information in yours than is required here.

 

I would not include a roof framing page, but I show a trusss in my section. I see your section have detail 7, but i dont see it on the section. you have a 7-8 but that is the floor not the roof

 

Thank you!

Yes, I did include way more information than is required by this particular building department.  But I wanted this to be practice for if I ever get a client in a stricter jurisdiction.  I lived in Seminole County, FL and they require all of their submitted plans to be architect or engineer stamped.  I'm glad not all jurisdictions are like that.

 

I'm not using trusses.  It's all going to be rafters for the roof.

 

Yeah, about 7-8.  I wasn't sure how to separate those without having another section camera.  7 is for the roof and 8 is for the floor.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, Greg_NY61 said:

Not sure the type of soil this house be sitting on, but that would be one hell of a concrete pour... 51yrd. of concrete for a footing and foundation for a little house. Also why would you set brick on the angle iron and not a concrete ledge?

 

I looked up the soil type for this location and it is considered silty and clay-ish.  I when I looked up the soil type in the code for footing size this is where it fell in the table.  Yeah, I thought the same thing.  Big chunky footing!  But I figured it was needed since it appears the soil will give way fairly easily.  However, after I made all of the drawings I did some more research about possible ledge in the area and that seems to be a concern also.  Apparently, it can appear anywhere from 2' - 6' below the soil surface.  If ledge is found, then the owner will have to decide if he wants to excavate or make the basement much smaller.  Or I guess, move the house further back because the lot does slope down 10' about half way back from the road.

 

Thank you!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, para-CAD said:

Anita III

 

If you're from Portugal, this is very good in matching what is typical in America, so congratulations.   I see you're drawing it for a city in Kentucky.

 

On sheet two, under general framing notes, typically the language I would use is all dimensions are from face of framing or foundation, not the framing layer because in Chief there are layers, but then in reality there might be layers as well, and it just makes it more specific.

 

On sheet two, there is two different uses of the word undimensioned, which is not even really a word.  The first use is all one word and the second use under electrical notes has a hyphen in between the first two letters and the third letter.

 

Maybe that should be rephrased and you could run that text through AI and have it rephrase it for you, but it should say something like all doors that are not dimensioned or something like that.

 

On sheet 4, there are dimensions to the sixteenth of an inch that show, to me, sloppiness, and you should move the walls to the nearest whole or half inch. So on the left, where it says 12'-3-15/16", it should actually be lengthened to be 12'-4". The whole building is a weird size; 30'-9-7/8" should be 30'-10". There's no concrete guy on planet earth that's going to nail that 1/8", so put it on your plans to the nearest inch or half inch, but nothing smaller. The only time dimensions get as small as that is if you're connecting an angled wall to a horizontal or vertical wall and dimensioning over to that point, which often will have a very small or odd remainder.  This whole structure on the foundation should be 30'-10" wide by 28'-10" deep or tall, up and down on the sheet, that is.

 

What is strange is your floor plan view for first and second floor have dimensions that look much better, a 30' wide. The building is 30'-0" wide by 28'-0" deep so I'm guessing the foundation is out over the brick in its dimensions but still, they need to not be to a 1/16". In reality not even to an 1/8 and your hallway is 3'-7-7/8"

 

Are you planning on stick framing this roof or using trusses?

 

Sheet 7. By looking at your elevations, it looks like you're using 11-7/8" I-joists for the first floor and second floor but where is your saved plan view that shows the foundation with the floor framing in it and the second floor framing so that you can show how you frame around your stair openings and stuff?  You have room on sheet four to copy and paste your foundation saved plan view and rename it floor framing and actually draw the joists or at least indicate how the joists are being installed.   the two elevations on the left have the first floor top of plate at the correct elevation. The two on the right are off and not what they should be. Are you dimensioning to something different? 

 

Sheet 10:
Detail 8   It calls out 2x12 floor joists or I joists. It should say joists per plan, and then somewhere on your plan, you should annotate the size of materials.

 

Detail 7.  Again, you are specifying 2x12 rafter, and I've framed many houses in Kentucky and Tennessee, and the largest rafter we used was 2x8, so I'm curious why you're specifying 2x12.

 

Stairs with 11 inch treads.pdf 82.99 kB · 6 downloads

Thank you so much for your detailed critique!

I grew up in Seminole County, just north of Orlando, FL and just recently moved to Portugal.  I "arrived" 9 months before the mouse.  My father was an electrical contractor and did a lot of work in and around the greater Orlando area when it first began to grow rapidly.

 

I will update my wording for the framing dimensions.  I knew that using the word "layer" was not appropriate and couldn't think of a better term.

 

Yeah, "undimensioned" is not a word.  Again, I couldn't think of any other way to say what I was trying to convey.  I will definitely take your advice and try to reword that better.  Muito obrigada!

 

Regarding dimensions on sheet 4.  Yes, I did notice that, too, and I should've corrected that.  The home was designed from the inside out, which should explain why the dimensions are so weird.  :(  I will correct all of that.

 

Yes, I planned on using rafters since there was a lot of attic space that could be potentially used as storage.

 

Thank you for the catch on sheet 7.  I had a hard time having Chief measure to the same elevation from one elevation view to the next.  I'm wanting to indicate the sub floor for each level and the top of place for each level and it just couldn't seem to find those!  Very frustrating.  I must be doing something wrong, but I'm not sure what.  :(

 

Sheet 10:  Thank you for that!  The owner has much less experience with construction than I do, not that I have any great amount of knowledge.  The owner is trying to save costs and I'm not sure what the construction company is going to use.  If it were me, I would go with the I-joists.  So I will spec those.  Thank you, again!

 

Sheet 7: I believe this must've been an automatic setting in Chief and I just went with it.  However, I should've checked the code or some other resource to see if a smaller rafter could've been used.  They definitely don't have to worry about snow load in that location.  I spent 16 years in the mountains of Maine, and that was definitely a consideration.  ;)

 

Thank you for the stair cut calculator results.  Did I do something wrong on my stairs?  I thought I had stayed with the min/max for tread and riser...

 

Thank you, again, sir for your critique!

Lisa

Tenha um bom dia!!!

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not sure how they do things in Kentucky but around here when dealing with silty and clay soils, a soil test is done 1st and after that the footing and foundation is designed based on that, I wouldn't rely on  “standardized code charts” without performing a soil test. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, para-CAD said:

So I'm using Grokbot and I had it create a plan checking bot and ran your plan through it. Like most AI, it generates a whole bunch of stuff, which may or may not be accurate, but in some instances it did a great job.plan-review.pdf

Thank you!  I don't have access to those tools.  Or should I say, I don't want to pay for them at this time.  :)  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Greg_NY61 said:

Not sure how they do things in Kentucky but around here when dealing with silty and clay soils, a soil test is done 1st and after that the footing and foundation is designed based on that, I wouldn't rely on  “standardized code charts” without performing a soil test. 

Thank you!  I will ask the owner if he wants to do that.  There's also a concern that there might be some ledge about 2' - 6' down so that might be a good next step.  He has mentioned that the builder can put any foundation on it that he wants.  I don't know if the building department would require another set of plans to issue another permit for a different type of foundation.  When I spoke to them on the phone, they seemed more concerned with making sure the setbacks were honored.  I've lived in a small community where the criteria for getting a permit were much less stringent than where I grew up in, just north of Orlando.  :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

33 minutes ago, OneChickNoHammer said:

Thank you!  I will ask the owner if he wants to do that.  There's also a concern that there might be some ledge about 2' - 6' down so that might be a good next step.  He has mentioned that the builder can put any foundation on it that he wants.  I don't know if the building department would require another set of plans to issue another permit for a different type of foundation.  When I spoke to them on the phone, they seemed more concerned with making sure the setbacks were honored.  I've lived in a small community where the criteria for getting a permit were much less stringent than where I grew up in, just north of Orlando.  :)

Yes, building departments use to be less lenient, but with all the building collapses, residential construction failures, code change, etc they asking for more and more details.Around here even if you need to bring a few trucks of fill to a site some jurisdictions asking for soil test to be performed to make sure its not contaminated.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

25 minutes ago, Greg_NY61 said:

Yes, building departments use to be less lenient, but with all the building collapses, residential construction failures, code change, etc they asking for more and more details.Around here even if you need to bring a few trucks of fill to a site some jurisdictions asking for soil test to be performed to make sure its not contaminated.

Wow!  And I thought Seminole County, FL was strict.  LOL!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, OneChickNoHammer said:

Thank you!  I will ask the owner if he wants to do that.  There's also a concern that there might be some ledge about 2' - 6' down so that might be a good next step.  He has mentioned that the builder can put any foundation on it that he wants.  I don't know if the building department would require another set of plans to issue another permit for a different type of foundation.  When I spoke to them on the phone, they seemed more concerned with making sure the setbacks were honored.  I've lived in a small community where the criteria for getting a permit were much less stringent than where I grew up in, just north of Orlando.  :)

The code is fairly conservative with soil bearing values, so 1500 psf for clay/silt soil is a good starting point unless there is buried stumps and organics or high groundwater.  The structure is small and only 2 stories, so the design loads on the footings are not large.  If there is bedrock, the concern I would have is differential settlement when part of the foundation is on rock and part is on soil.

If the homeowner is on a budget, a couple test holes could tell a lot without the need of geotech testing.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

34 minutes ago, ChristianA said:

The code is fairly conservative with soil bearing values, so 1500 psf for clay/silt soil is a good starting point unless there is buried stumps and organics or high groundwater.  The structure is small and only 2 stories, so the design loads on the footings are not large.  If there is bedrock, the concern I would have is differential settlement when part of the foundation is on rock and part is on soil.

If the homeowner is on a budget, a couple test holes could tell a lot without the need of geotech testing.

Thank you!  I will discuss that with him the next time we speak.  :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now
 Share