Recommended Posts

I have a strange problem with floor joists on this project.  Once again a client-supplied file that I have made lots of adjustments to, but when I generate floor joists each room on the second floor generates a rim joist around it, and the joists go all over the place.

 

Here is a view of the first floor prior to generating joists.686080809_FloorPlan.thumb.jpg.6d38d1d42bc609c9419c13b8dfb953e5.jpg

 

And here is the view of automatically generated joists 688320748_FloorJoistsCreated.thumb.jpg.e973b9c2a29759eaa0b0ec78f095afa8.jpg

 

Note the seemingly random direction of joists in closets and in some floor panels.  Why is the program generating floor joists around each second floor room?

Floor_Framing_Problem.zip

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

As a side note:

This is the same plan that was causing double floor layers that Michael sorted out.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I don't even know where to start, but here's where YOU can start...

-Inspect the ceiling heights.  They're not consistent.

-Inspect the Joist Direction Arrows.  There are a whole bunch of these that may be giving some specific instructions that you may not actually be wanting.

-Check walls that are set as Bearing Walls.  There are some of these that may be giving some specific instructions to the joists that you may not be wanting.

-Check the walls that are set to Hang Floor Platform Above On Wall.  There are some of these that are affecting how the joists build as well

-Look for Bearing Lines.  There are also some of these that may be adversely affecting how your joists build.

 

All these issues are similar to the last issue I inspected for you.  It's not a problem with the program.  It's really just a bunch of faulty settings. 

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Michael,

 

Thanks again.  I will check all of those, this particular project is really giving me heartburn.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Doug,  Did the client draw that or did they buy an "Almost Complete" plan file from someone they fired ?

 

There is some pretty nasty work in there for sure.   Good luck.

 

Noticed a bunch of walls on the upper level that were not at Default Bottom Height.

 

Also some broken roof framing.

 

Sometimes when things are that messy or complex it is good to get all of your layout views set up so deficiencies are easier to see as they would show in the final layout.  Then you can just deal with the worst first.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok so I checked all the ceiling heights and corrected all of them.  Then I made sure all floor elevations were correct for the first and second floor.  

Next I turned all the interior walls to "No Room Definition" and the floor joists generated correctly.

 

So then I deleted a few walls on the second floor, and the joists under the walls corrected.  So I replaced the wall with a "vanilla" interior wall, 1/2" drywall, 2 x 4 studs 16" OC.and the damned system once again created a rim joist under the vanilla wall.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I tried to duplicate the problem in a fresh plan file, and if I change any second storey floor height it makes rim joists around that room.  If I make that room go back to default floor height, then the problem goes away.  That isn't the case in my client's plan.  That plan was created by him using Home Designer.  

 

For a first-timer, he did a remarkable job of getting the as-built design done but with a bucket load of hand grenades as well.  The double floor generation was one such problem that Michael managed to uncover, but this rim joist and floor joist direction phenomenon just has me baffled.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You mention changing the floor/ceiling heights and changing the wall types, but did you check those other settings I mentioned?  They were all major contributing factors in that plan.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

@Doug_NIf this is a renovation / addition project, why would you model the existing framing? You can reduce your heartburn by eliminating all existing framing. There's simpler ways to indicate the relationship between proposed new elements and the existing. Why not save your energy to show new items only?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 minute ago, robdyck said:

@Doug_NIf this is a renovation / addition project, why would you model the existing framing? You can reduce your heartburn by eliminating all existing framing. There's simpler ways to indicate the relationship between proposed new elements and the existing. Why not save your energy to show new items only?

Robert,

 

The problem is that there is a mix of new framing matching up with the existing framing.  There are second storey additions to the rear and the front of the house.  several existing second storey joists are going to be removed and replaced with cantilevered joists.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13 hours ago, Alaskan_Son said:

You mention changing the floor/ceiling heights and changing the wall types, but did you check those other settings I mentioned?  They were all major contributing factors in that plan.

Yup, I did all of that.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
12 minutes ago, Doug_N said:

Yup, I did all of that.

 

...and have you made any additional progress?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Ok guys Michael came through again.  There was still one closet with a slightly different floor level, but the real answer was a new feature in X12 framing groups.  More on this later. 

 

Thanks Michael.

  • Like 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now

  • Member Statistics

    28148
    Total Members
    6254
    Most Online
    Yusefun
    Newest Member
    Yusefun
    Joined
  • Similar Content

    • By cjanderson66
      I have designed a very large deck and the client wanted to take 2' off in one direction and another 3' in the other.  I have custom framed the deck framing per the engineer and don't want to change the framing.  The problem is that I need to rebuild the deck in order to not show the decking from overhanging the framing.  Is there a way to just rebuild the decking and not the framing of the deck itself. as you can from the rendering shown below you can see that the decking overhangs the decking.  Everytime I rebuild it it changes the framing per CA.

    • By AlmiraDesign
      I am having a difficult time with the framing of the rafters; in regards to birds mouth specifically. I am looking for assistance as I have tried many different options in aligning them to the beams. Please help me! I'd greatly appreciate it!
       
      Ps, I only began to notice the difference, when I changed depth of hip rafters to 3.5".

    • By SpeleoWorm
      I have created a number of different wall types to show proper dimensions (i.e. when one side of the wall is 5/8" Type X and the other side is 1/2" drywall) as well as to calculate the correct material counts and to show the proper information in the schedules.  Unfortunately doing that seems to have a down side...it changes the framing as if they were separate walls instead of the same wall with different materials on them.  I have seen the following side effects (colors refer to screenshots below):
       
      (Green Arrow) In unfinished rooms such as an attic storage space which only has a subfloor but no drywall, the walls get pushed up into the rafters by what appears to be 3". (Red Arrows) The floor joists and top/bottom plates are cut in the middle when they should be continuous pieces of wood.  In addition, you can see that the walls which are produced are not boxed at the end...the top & bottom plates stick out at the end. (Purple Arrow) Parts of the gable wall are not created.  In this case you could argue that it is not needed, but if a builder makes a wall he is not going to leave a hole in it. (Blue Arrows) An extra stud is added to a room that has no drywall, and therefore doesn't need nailer studs.  In addition, it looks like the other stud needed as a nailer for the finished room in the middle is missing from the plan view of the framing (see 2nd screenshot).  
      Am I doing this all wrong (creating separate wall types), or is there a way to use them and fix (any of) the issues I mentioned?
       
      Thanks in advance for any help!
       
      PS - I am a little surprised that the wall finish is not part of the room settings (like the floor & ceiling already are)...that would allow you to have continuous walls and still have different materials in each room (i.e. greenboard in the bath, 5/8" type X in a garage, unfinished in an attic, etc.
       
        
      Example of Wall Issue.plan
    • By MichaelJerome
      Hi Again,
      After sending this plan to my engineer he has requested several things that are list in the pdf files.
      I can not combine framing layer 4 and 2 that are basically the same wall but separated. With the headers that the engineer is suggesting I will have to raise the ceiling, roof and trusses. I also need to have a soffit retained over the entry for lighting but have the outside ends match with no boxed soffit.  The are layers in the wall that appear as shapes in the drywall that I cannot seem to find or eliminate.  The windows cannot be lowered since the closet ceiling and the closet roof limit the movement in the wall.  I have drawn red lines for the framing that the engineer has requested but can't place the framing on the same layer. I would appreciate any insight on how to accomplish this so I can get it back to him for review and have accurate details for the layout and city plan review.
       
      Thank you,
      Michael 
      Megale Center Plan 2.7.20.zip
      2nd Wall Layer 4 Megale Center Plan 2.7.20.pdf
      Megale Center Plan 2 2.7.20.pdf
      Megale Center Plan 2.7.20.pdf
      Wall Layer 2 Megale Center Plan 2.7.20.pdf
      Wall Layer 4 Megale Center Plan 2.7.20.pdf
    • By RichM1
      Summary: We're creating a vaulted tray ceiling in a house that started as a double-wide mobile home. I want to model the existing "trusses" so that I can figure out how to do the rafters to frame out the new ceiling. I cannot figure out how to do this though. 
       
      Details: 
      This house started out as a double-wide mobile home. It's been remodeled several times, huge portions added, walls rebuilt in places, rooms moved, walls removed. But the roof structure through the middle of the house is a 2.5/12 pitch, framed as follows: 2x2 rafter, 2x2 joist, 16" OC, with 12" pieces of 1/4" paneling used as gussets every 12". The tall wall has 1/2" plywood as a ridge beam.  I attached a drawing that shows each side. 
       
      I tried changing the rafter and joist settings to 1.5" x 1.5", but it insists on building roof framing with 6" rafters floating above the walls, and framing the tall wall with studs that are in the room wall below. 

      I tried to manually draw the framing in like the CAD detail drawing I attached, but I can't figure out how to rotate the 2x2 rafter to the 2.5/12 pitch angle. I figured I'd draw one "truss" manually, and then replicate/copy it across every 16". But after about 6 hours (admittedly I'm new to this app) I still couldn't figure it out. 
       
      I put both sides together, and added the 2x6 rafters and 2x4 cross brace. Then we plan to cut the trusses back flush with the rafters and brace. The wall will be coming out of the middle. There's no code here, unincorporated county, so no building inspection to send this through.
       
      Is there a way I can take this CAD drawing and use it for the actual rafters - extrude the 2D shapes into 3D?