marisco

Butterfly roof with saddle or cricket

Recommended Posts

Hi Guys,

newish user - using X8 on a project I am doing for a semi detached house. I am having a hard time enforcing my vision of the roof into the project with how chiefs roofs work with my limited knowledge. What I am attempting to do is to make a butterfly roof with the shed slopes front and back and a saddle running between them to shed water. When I get the saddle/cricket in place and try to join it to the other planes, the roof goes all wonky (or I need to extend the eaves to almost 4'-0"! Any tips on how I can get this to work? alternatively I could try a troughed butterfly - just not sure how to add a gutter between the shed roofs.... Any help is much appreciated. I'm really starting to like Chief, but these few things just irk me....

semi project butterfly.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Something like this?

 

Are you trying to auto build the roof?

 

 

marisco 1.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

More savvy folks than I might be able to auto-build this, but I would do it manually.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was trying to manually do it - auto-build gave less than desirable results (probably due to the cantilevers. the pitch is 2/12. but yes Solver - what you are showing is what I am trying to accomplish. here is the second floor underneath

The biggest issue is that if I split the planes and move to where I think the ridge should meet the shed roofs, my planes are all off - if I use the join tool it places the roof in odd above below areas as well.

 

i was thinking of working out where the exact middle should be and try from there manually, but there has to be an easier way.....

2nd floor.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This type of roof can definitely be done almost completely automatically.  Here's a quick example.  Note that you can either break the wall like I did on the top OR you can use the Gable/Roof Line tool...

 

Roof.jpgPlan.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Remember the Fascia Height and overhang dimension needs to match for the roof planes to join correctly.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Roof Drainage?

What are the proposed solutions for collection roof drainage from 

the proposed butterfly-saddle design?

Appears there will be a substantial flow of water to each outlet.

 

The traditional butterfly uses a wide central box gutter as a holding

reservoir that then allows progressive water flow to the end rainwater heads.

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I agree, water disposal is going to be a big problem.

Even with huge rainwater heads, I think you are going to have problems.

 

Here is a similar one I did a few years back.

I designed a near flat central roof that fell to each side and the water was then picked up in some oversized gutters.

This worked well with no water problems.

New Image_171.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Drainage is THE issue with an inverted gable. The saddle method is not great, if you can I would suggest glenw's method. More control there.

If you do have a saddle be sure to leave yourself some eave to have a large scupper and downspout.

 

It is possible to do a lot of the roof automatically but you will almost certainly have to manually edit some of the planes.

 

 

 

Untitled 4.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

decide to go with Glennw's route - not that we get that much rainfall/snowfall (320mm/126mm per year) but will also make for easier framing. Great idea, thanks.

 

I know the skylights are not the best idea on that low pitched roof - just asking to fail - client insists they need them in the bathrooms.....

 

colour matching the fascia trim to the windows and soffit to the decks

 

 

roof 2.jpgroof.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now

  • Member Statistics

    27450
    Total Members
    6254
    Most Online
    Elliot
    Newest Member
    Elliot
    Joined
  • Similar Content

    • By 9atatimer
      I'm using X11 premier on a mac -- I have an exterior garage wall (with a centered garage door) and a gable end -- I'd like to split the attic wall of the gable end into 3 parts -- the central region above the garage door, and the left and right, to have a different material above the garage door.

      I have Default Settings > Roof > Auto Rebuild Roof set to Off
      I have Default Settings > Framing > Automatically Build Floor and Ceiling Framing Off on all framing types.
      I have Default Settings > Walls > General Walls > Auto Rebuild Attic Walls set to Off

      If I delete the roof and ceiling planes with Build > Roof > Delete [X] and then use the Build > Roof > Build Roof ... dialog to rebuild the roof and attic from scratch -- I leave the Auto Rebuild Roofs set to Off, to be clear -- and then edit the resulting gable roof on the attic layer, I can split it twice to produce the three separate wall sections, but once I change the exterior material on any of the sections, the three wall segments get replaced with a single wall again.  The new wall has my selected material, but that does me no good as I need the distinct secgments.

      Anyone know what setting do I need to turn off to maintain the manually edited gable end?  Or is this a mac bug?

      Or, barring that, does anyone know what approach will let me give the desired finish detail (attached a pic of a freehand elevation)?

    • By blueriver
      I'm using Chief Architect Premier X11
       
      I have all these little 'X's can someone please tell me how to get rid of them?  I've been really playing around with the roof and i THINK they are from that but at the same time i have a couple random ones outside where the roof is -- i cannot get them to go away. Help!
       
      thanks in advance
      Lauren

    • By chief69
      Hello, We are having a hard time getting  the design program to do the roof right. We have tried with Sketchup and it got the closest. It's hard to describe I have attached a few pics with a decent idea of what we are trying to do.
       
      The Garage is a shed roof as well as the breeze way, but they are at different angles. The house is a butterfly style with the V running at a angle. WE do not care what the pitch ends up being on any of the roofs.
       
      Anyone know how to do this. I have been trying for hours and the program goes crazy every time. Esp with the all 3 roofs at different angles with each other. I have attached a copy of the plan we made and some pics from sketchup because that program got the closest to what we are trying to do.
       
      Thanks
       
      Chris
      New house v1.plan




    • By MN_JohnH
      I wonder why my second floor loft flooring is sticking through the roof and can be seen on the outside of the building?


    • By mprovost129
      Hi all. I'm fairly new to the software and have only been using it since October. I have a client who wants a wood framed chimney extruding from the middle of the roof up from the gas fireplace. I've tried a bunch of different options to make this work but can't figure it out. Can someone please tell me how to draw walls on top of the roof?
       
      Thank you!