X17 Custom Railing

[JonathanK]

I made a custom porch railing with a custom newel that is an 8x8 with the Simpson bracket and hardware.

Anyways, I've noticed that when I draw the walls with this custom railing, and I use RIGHT click, it makes my newels "manual" spacing, even though it's all set to Automatic.

When I draw the walls with this custom railing and I use LEFT click...it makes everything correct.

 

Is this a bug, or is there a reason behind this?

Railing Issue.zip Porch Railing.calibz

[Joe_Carrick]

I think that's Intended behavior.  The right click allows customization.

Edited 19 hours ago by Joe_Carrick

[JonathanK]

Thanks, Joe.

That's all good and well, but wondering why the top wall on the left doesn't have the "customization"?

 

I always just assumed that right click was a continuous draw option, but apparently there is more to right click than I thought?...

[JonathanK]

And...maybe thinking on this a little further...if right click allows customization, how does that work for walls and other items?

[Joe_Carrick]

29 minutes ago, JonathanK said:

And...maybe thinking on this a little further...if right click allows customization, how does that work for walls and other items?

The customization of newel spacing is only for railing walls.  Basically it's just like continuous drawing of walls except that it thinks the next point is a newel. vs a corner.

Edited 18 hours ago by Joe_Carrick

[JonathanK]

Can anyone from CA confirm this, or am I making a big deal of something that's not a big deal?

[Renerabbitt]

4 hours ago, JonathanK said:

Thanks, Joe.

That's all good and well, but wondering why the top wall on the left doesn't have the "customization"?

 

I always just assumed that right click was a continuous draw option, but apparently there is more to right click than I thought?...

Not sure what you mean, these are identical:

[JonathanK]

Hey @Renerabbitt.  They dimension identically, but the the three railings on the left side are yellow.  That signifies that you can manually adjust the newels.  So if you click on the yellow box, and tab through, you can select it and move it.

On the right side, that feature is not available.

The interesting thing, is that if you open those railings, you can see that the newel spacing is set to Automatic.  So then why are they showing up as yellow, if it's set to Automatic?

It's probably not a huge deal...my workflow is that if I know I'm making multiple walls in succession, I use right click.  If not, I use left click.  So it's more of a little switch in my brain than any real issue.

Edited 12 hours ago by JonathanK

[JonathanK]

The other strange thing is that all the walls on the left were drawn with right click method...so how come all four walls don't have the newels shown as yellow?

[Renerabbitt]

12 minutes ago, JonathanK said:

That signifies that you can manually adjust the newels

No that signifies that the CAD block for your newel post failed to properly generate. you can share your newel post file here so we can take a look.
You can tab through and move newels on any railing if you tab close enough to a newel post.
If instead you manually change the CAD block for your newel post to just an x polyline I bet that issue goes away

Edited 12 hours ago by Renerabbitt

[DBCooper]

Something is not working right.  Rene is right because it looks like the railing is losing the cad block symbol.  It's weird that you only lose it when you draw it with the right-click but not with the left.  I would send in a bug report to Chief.

 

You can probably fix any railings that are messed up by just replacing the newel posts with the good one you have in your library.