GMTinc

Lower shed roofs cutting attic walls

Recommended Posts

What is the best way to resolve the issue of lower shed or bay roofs, covering projections in gable walls, cutting the automatically generated gable attic wall?  This, I am sure, has been asked before, but I cannot readily find such a thread.  Thanks for your help

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Most roof planes can be raised or lowered manually using the "Transform-Replicate dialog" using that dialog's "Move tools"

 Te exceptions are Under the Window tools bay and box bay, those roofs are part of a symbol and cannot be separately edited but such symbol windows can be edited by moving its handles in a camera or elevation camera views. Try it and see for yourself

 

DJP

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for these replies.  I am not in the office at the moment and will check the plan tomorrow afternoon.  I think there is a basic misunderstanding in the last reply.   The problem is as foolows:

 

1.  There is a cantilevered area on a gable, which requires its own shed roof.  When a roof plane is manually built, the attic wall and frieze, above it dissappears.  

2.  I have tried to lower the roof plane at its upper reach where it contacts the waa. The thought being that it intersects too deeply into the wall; however, that makes no difference.  If the plane is completely removed, then, as expected all the wall of the projection extend up to the rafters.

3.  It occurs to me I may need to use a room divider to make the projection a separate room, even though it is just part of a room, in order to avoid this behavior.  I have not tried that.  It is a possible solution in keeping with some of the bizarre ans inobvious efforts that often have to be made tp get auto,ated  CAD programs to generate properly.  Such thing are never well documented.  I usually avoid such things by avoiding all but the very basic auto,ated features, but in this instance I was trying to explore better how the program would handle such a situation

 

if you have more advice on the strength of what I have presented here, it is ,ost welcome. Otherwise, I will try the separate room gambit tomorrow.

 

As always thanks

 

Gary

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Probably no one is still monitoring this thread, but I thought I would add the results of my experimentation.

 

If I continue the exterior wall straight through the bump out for the shed, the attic wall draws properly along with the freize etc.  However if I break that wall at each side of the bump out, the attic wall will still draw correctly.  But, if I then change that broken segment into a invisible wall, the attic wall and frieze split above it as with the initial problem.  This appears to be the issue anytime the room below, in any plan, is extended out and has a floor, such as a manually drawn bay or shed.  I am sure there is a solution for this, but as I indicated, I normally do not use automated elevations and therefore have little experience with such unexpected behaviors.  I know many, if not most, chief users do use those features and doubtless know how to handle this situation.  It is difficult to add unusual detail to automated elevations, in my past experience, and that is why I have avoided them; however, recent new features and improvements have made such possibilities more practical and I have seen some very good examples of such work....I just do not know enough about how some of it is accomplished and I have found not much in the way of instruction.  So, please help an old guy get up to speed.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have managed to get the gable walls to close but am unable to edit the frieze to go over those areas.  I unlocked the roof trim layer, but when I attempt to edit, the line edits but the frieze does not appear on the newly edited line except to the extent as before the edit.  I also have no real clue as to how I closed the attic wall gap.  I was attempting to manually edit the gable attic walls (there are two, one on each side of the shed projection).  I was having no luck until one of the adjustments worked and I am not sure what it was.  I am sure there is a better way to approach this situation.  One other matter.  This is a long wall with a gable in the middle, which does not extend to either end of the wall.  The balance of the wall is eave wall in terms of roof.  If that makes any particular difference.  I can attempt to replicate the original issue and post a plan, if that will truly be a help.

 

Gary

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now

  • Member Statistics

    29128
    Total Members
    9156
    Most Online
    jharmer
    Newest Member
    jharmer
    Joined
  • Similar Content

    • By larsonem
      Hello, I am looking for some advise on how to improve the intersecting roofs which will overlap gable roof onto the hip roof so water avoid the corner on an addition project for myself. In the "elevation" picture, the hip roof to left is existing roof that will be extended to insect the new addition gable roof to the right.  We like floor plan layout and ceiling heights but having trouble getting the roof line correct. I have attached the plan file and some snapshots.
       
      Second question: How would I create the roofline extension like the attached "roof line" photo?   
       
      Thanks for help.



      Dugan #8D.plan
    • By Noremac
      Hello there!
       
      I'm new to chief as of a few weeks ago. I'm really loving how in-depth you can get with it. Hopefully this isn't to much of a newbie question that is easily answered somewhere else but I have seen anything on it. I'm trying to attach a shed roof to a gable. I have a feeling this is something similar to a porch roof, but after messing with it for a few hours I cant figure it out. 
       
      This is what I'm go
                                    
       
      Here is where I'm at. 
       
      I've attached my plan if that helps!
      I'm using x12 
       
      Thanks!
      -Cam
      Piper_3rd Round 2_4_2021.plan
    • By Taylork15
      Hi, 
      I am having some problems with getting the garage roof to be an 11/12 pitch and the attached house being 8/12 pitch, one of the roof planes is part of the garage and apart of the house. I am new to this and can't draw the roof manually very well. I have been using the auto roof and just changing the settings. 
       
      Thank you!May- Lot 73.plan 
       

    • By Designer100
      can anyone explain how and help me enclose between this new gable roof and ceiling. Also looking toward house thru gable closing in with Hardi-siding. The old roof is showing thru and something else when I do a rendering (see attached). Need to look good for a client in 3 D. They are adding a roof over existing 10' x 20' patio. 
       
      thank you if you can help.
       
      Newell Cheatheam
      CA 12
      newell@newellcheatheam.com 

      Patio Remodeling.plan
    • By j2narchitecture
      Hello. 
      I am starting a remodeling plan based off of an existing plan.
      When I delete an exterior first floor wall (i.e. a wall that is being demolished), an attic wall shows in its place and the floor disappears in perspective overview.
      Why are attic walls being automatically generated for my first floor exterior walls?
      Any suggestion on how to fix this would be greatly appreciated. 
       
      TIA !
       
       
      Remodel 1.plan