GMTinc

Gable over lower Roof

Recommended Posts

Doing an as-built.  I created the basic roof using auto-roof and then edited it manually to raise one section higher.  This created a gable over a lower roof.  I cannot get either that gable wall or the eaves to cooperate.  I am attaching the file. 

 

You will note that the gable in question is showing a boxed eave on the front.  This is what was selected in all the dialogues; however, the other eave of that same gable is showing a continuous return.  In all of that, the abutting roof 2nd floor lower wall, is in the picture for some reason and interfering with the generation of the gable wall and is apparently the end point for the continuous eave return.  Interestingly, you will note there is a small bump out on the rear of the building with no roof.  If I generate a manual shed roof over this section, the single boxed eave changes to a continuous return eave.

 

I usually build roofs manually, but things like this usually cause problems.  Thought I would try, as is always suggested, to start with an automatic roof and manually adjust it hoping to eliminate joining issues that are often hard to find with manual roofs.  This one seems to have several issues and I need help.

 

Oh yeah,......... using X-10

 

Thanks

Dossenbach Existing Plan.plan

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I just guessing ...

 

Always good to attach an image of the problem areas or leave a note in the plan itself.

 

ct1.thumb.jpg.d1b9cb5ec8eca9a3d578183510af3cdf.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I was just guessing also.  Last time I posted, I was admonished for not including the plan file.  Since this issue would require multiple images, and I assume, some access to the settings, to resolve, I thought I should send the file.  But, I apologize for not sending images.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

That is close to what I am trying to achieve

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What's missing? You had returns on that wall that I removed. Were the supposed to be there and tie in to the lower gable?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

I have not looked back at the plan, but I thought I had made all of those wall dialogues to not have returns. Which wall did you remove?  The one projecting out and stopping the continuous eve?  I had deleted that wall, which is basically the second floor wall at the lower eave, but it had no effect??   What you show is what is existing with the exception of some type of trim between the siding and the brick veneer.  I know I will have to do that with other tools.

 

I apologize for not understanding what you did, but would appreciate a fuller explanation as this sort of thing, at lease similar in nature, has often created issues for me.

 

Thanks

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

This attic and the brick wall on the right both have returns checked.

 

ct1.thumb.jpg.54cb817b4297006aa93a776a5f8fc458.jpg

 

 

This roof plane needs a jog put in it, and the opposite side needs to be pulled back so it's not inside the wall.

 

ct2.thumb.jpg.53f67624f32b5a9bcf98a2dfbf18a463.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

You were absolutely correct.  I made those changes and then moved roof planes and attic walls in order to make gable friezes be correct as well as aligning gable wall with lower brick veneer.  All that is left is the transition I mentioned which I can resolve easily.  In doing all of this I found that manipulating the walls and/or roof planes, several times made the continuous eaves reappear.  Not sure what that is, but at least I know where to start looking for such things.

 

I have used Chief a long time, since v.4 I think, but have found that the 3d elevations and roofs were more trouble than I wanted, unless everything was very simple.  CA has come a long way in what can be represented in those views and I have started trying to adapt.  But, I'm old, crotchety, curmudgeonly and hand drafted for many, many, many years...a bad combination for assimilating technology, I'm afraid. 

 

Thank you immensely for your prompt reply and your help.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now

  • Member Statistics

    27475
    Total Members
    6254
    Most Online
    slickrick1530
    Newest Member
    slickrick1530
    Joined
  • Similar Content

    • By 9atatimer
      I'm using X11 premier on a mac -- I have an exterior garage wall (with a centered garage door) and a gable end -- I'd like to split the attic wall of the gable end into 3 parts -- the central region above the garage door, and the left and right, to have a different material above the garage door.

      I have Default Settings > Roof > Auto Rebuild Roof set to Off
      I have Default Settings > Framing > Automatically Build Floor and Ceiling Framing Off on all framing types.
      I have Default Settings > Walls > General Walls > Auto Rebuild Attic Walls set to Off

      If I delete the roof and ceiling planes with Build > Roof > Delete [X] and then use the Build > Roof > Build Roof ... dialog to rebuild the roof and attic from scratch -- I leave the Auto Rebuild Roofs set to Off, to be clear -- and then edit the resulting gable roof on the attic layer, I can split it twice to produce the three separate wall sections, but once I change the exterior material on any of the sections, the three wall segments get replaced with a single wall again.  The new wall has my selected material, but that does me no good as I need the distinct secgments.

      Anyone know what setting do I need to turn off to maintain the manually edited gable end?  Or is this a mac bug?

      Or, barring that, does anyone know what approach will let me give the desired finish detail (attached a pic of a freehand elevation)?

    • By blueriver
      I'm using Chief Architect Premier X11
       
      I have all these little 'X's can someone please tell me how to get rid of them?  I've been really playing around with the roof and i THINK they are from that but at the same time i have a couple random ones outside where the roof is -- i cannot get them to go away. Help!
       
      thanks in advance
      Lauren

    • By chief69
      Hello, We are having a hard time getting  the design program to do the roof right. We have tried with Sketchup and it got the closest. It's hard to describe I have attached a few pics with a decent idea of what we are trying to do.
       
      The Garage is a shed roof as well as the breeze way, but they are at different angles. The house is a butterfly style with the V running at a angle. WE do not care what the pitch ends up being on any of the roofs.
       
      Anyone know how to do this. I have been trying for hours and the program goes crazy every time. Esp with the all 3 roofs at different angles with each other. I have attached a copy of the plan we made and some pics from sketchup because that program got the closest to what we are trying to do.
       
      Thanks
       
      Chris
      New house v1.plan




    • By MN_JohnH
      I wonder why my second floor loft flooring is sticking through the roof and can be seen on the outside of the building?